Alexis: Read 4/7/19
A teenager wakes up in the middle of a pumpkin patch with amnesia. He doesnât know who he is, where he is, or whatâs going on. He only knows that he was shocked so badly that he couldnât move, causing his amnesia, and that he knows someone named Lazarus is dead, and someone just tried to kill him, as well.
Idlewind is like a mix between The Matrix and The Maze Runner. I donât usually go for sc-fi, but I found myself enjoying the change of pace. I truly loved the beginning of the book. I found it really original and creative, and I enjoyed Saganâs worldbuilding. I loved learning about Halloweenâs character alongside him as his memory slowly started to resurface. I liked Saganâs conversational writing style and I found Halloweenâs gothic character interesting.
I also enjoyed the structure of the book. The majority of the book is in first person from Halloweenâs POV, while excerpts in the beginning of each chapter focus on characters from the past. Sections called âPace Transmissionâs intersect the chapters. At first, these make no sense, but I found them helpful as the book progresses.
Itâs hard to talk about this book without giving anything away. I feel like itâs best to go into it without knowing much. My overall consensus of the book is that I loved the first ž of it, including the plot twists and reveals, but thought the ending fell flat. I also wasnât a fan of how the characters progressed, and I also didnât like the characterizations of the female characters. In that regard, Idlewild feels very early 2000âs.
However, if youâre in the mood for a creative, apocalyptic sci-fi read with a large dash of virtual reality, I definitely recommend it. Most of the book was 4 stars for me, but the ending knocked it down ½ a star.
VERDICT: 3 ½ stars
SPOILERS BELOW:
My biggest issue with the ending was the reveal of Mercutio as Lazarusâ killer. I felt like there wasnât any buildup or real evidence or motivations for this to make sense. I also didnât feel like I knew the secondary characters well enough, especially since Halloween himself was still figuring everyone else out. Because of this, Simone and Mercutioâs deaths didnât affect me, and Iâm not really sure I want to continue reading the series. Halloweenâs reaction to the ending felt a bit melodramatic, even for his already melodramatic character.