book reviewers – takes two to book review

Review: Red Demon by Sill Bihagia

October 1, 2025 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

An ARC package of Red Demon sits on a wall

Alexis:

Happy October 1st! 🎃

Thanks so much to author Sill Bihagia for sending me this beautiful ARC package.

Red Demon was released on September 16th! It’s a science fiction/fantasy book with found family and themes of coming of age, resilience, and redemption. It has a mystery woven throughout and some really interesting worldbuilding.⁣ The bioengineering concept was fascinating.

Overall, I enjoyed this one and appreciated Jesse’s resilience and will to survive. I liked reading from his POV, and my favorite part of the story was him forming a connection to his adopted brother, Asher.

My main critique is that the pacing in the first half dragged, as Jesse growing up and finding his new family took up a large part of the book. I love a good coming of age story, but since this was advertised as a fast paced book, I expected just a little more action and for the plot to move along faster; the actual plot didn’t start until the second half of the story. Additionally, the ending felt too abrupt.

VERDICT: ⭐⭐⭐/5

I have several more ARCs to read, and I look forward to digging into them this fall!

If you want to learn more about Red Demon, check out the synopsis below.

Synopsis:

On an isolated planet where unity is as engineered as its people, Jesse seeks the truth behind the slaughter of his family-starting with the immortal who spared him.

A century ago, two human lines nearly wiped each other out rather than acknowledge their shared humanity. But when Jesse’s mining town is slaughtered under mysterious circumstances, it’s clear ancient bigotries are still alive, and rebels have access to some magic or tech capable of wide-scale genocide.

The Red Demon bloodied her swords in that massacre-a bioengineered immortal left over from that century old war. Jesse expected her to be upholding his empire’s fragile peace, not killing her own. But Jesse is too optimistic and stubborn to break. Better days are coming, and he’s willing to take on an immortal to protect the life he’s rebuilt among the ashes.

Faruhar, the so-called Red Demon, is not the mastermind Jesse expects. Her fragmented mind is ravaged by guilt over crimes she cannot remember committing, and a code impressed on her by a few kind people she cannot forget.

Review: The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig

June 24, 2025June 22, 2025 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

The Knight and the Moth held over a book cart

Alexis: If you haven’t heard of The Knight and the Moth, are you living under a rock?

(Just kidding). But really, Rachel Gillig, the author of One Night Window, has been having a moment across social media with her new book.

The Knight and the Moth follows Sybil, who is just known as Six. She’s a Diviner, one of the prophetesses who live in the great cathedral. Her task is to dream, where she receives visions from six unearthly figures known as Omens.

But one day, the new boy king and his group of knights pay a visit so the king can have his future predicted. Among them is a mysterious knight, Rodrick, called Rory, who has no respect for Six’s dreams or even the Omens. When Six’s Diviner sisters start to disappear, she finds herself following Rory on a journey.

I don’t want to reveal too much more than that. The Knight and the Moth has the classic Gillig gothic atmosphere that I love. The dark way the Diviners dream was fascinating to me, and I really enjoyed learning about Six and her sisters.

I also really enjoyed the cast of characters. Sybil was a great main character, and I loved how strong yet emotionally vulnerable she is. I also equally loved Rory, and their chemistry and banter worked really well; the romance subplot in this was fantastic.

And, of course, there’s the gargoyle. The cathedral has stone gargoyles that are alive, and the main gargoyle, which becomes Six’s companion, is a true gem of a character who often brings welcome comic relief throughout the story.

Overall, my main critique is that I didn’t care for the actual quest plot. I didn’t find the actual Omens all that interesting (which could just be a me problem), and this played a huge role in the story. I did guess the two huge plot twists fairly early on. The pacing also felt a little off to me at times, especially in the first half.

That being said, I definitely still think this is worth a read, and I’m interested to see where the story goes in the next book, especially since the stakes will be even higher!

VERDICT: ⚒️⚒️⚒️.5/5

Review: The Devourer by Alison Ames

January 7, 2025 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

Alexis:

Happy Pub Day to The Devourer!

The Devourer is a YA fantasy with pirates, revenge, a monster sinking ships, and magic leaking into the world. It follows Adra, a young pirate captain. When her half-brother Cameron attacks their father and robs him of a priceless treasure map, he leaves him a shell of the pirate captain he once was. Now Adra’s only aim in life is to kill Cameron, retrieve her father’s map, and claim the treasure herself.

But her plans are thwarted by a young pirate captain named Quinn, as well as a monster called The Devourer that’s sinking ships. Now, she must strike a deal with the monster.

What I Liked:

Adra was a morally grey and well-rounded main character, and her relationship with her crew was interesting to read about. Diana, a girl who was turned into an osprey by bad magic, was my favorite character, and I wanted even more of her!

I also really vibed with Ames’ writing style, and I loved her descriptions.

The story also has sapphic and disability representation.

I don’t want to give anything away, but the overall plot and premise feels fresh and different, which I really appreciated in a YA read. The atmosphere of the book is fairly dark, but with enough humor to balance it out.

What I Didn’t Like As Much:

However, I found myself wanting even more monsters and mayhem. The premise of the book doesn’t really happen until halfway through the story, so the first half felt a little slow and the plot didn’t feel quite as urgent as I wanted it to. The ending also felt a little abrupt to me; I wanted more scenes with Cameron.

Verdict:

That being said, overall, this was a solid and enjoyable read. I was in the mood for a pirate story, so this hit the spot.

🌊🌊🌊🌊/5

Thank you to Netgalley and Page Street Publishing for my ARC in exchange for a review!

Review: The Will of the Many by James Islington

April 9, 2024April 8, 2024 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

The Will of the Many rests on a desk with a cloud wrist rest, a planner, and a cat sniffing the book.

Alexis:

Happy April! I hope you all have been reading some good books. One of my reading goals for this year is to pick up more adult fantasy books. I heard nothing but good things about The Will of the Many, so I grabbed it from the library.

I’m happy to say that it lived up to the hype!

The Will of the Many is one of those books where it’s good to go into it with little expectations. But here’s what you can know about it:

The main character, Vis, is such a great, well-rounded main character. He’s vicious, caring, and intelligent.
A main theme is colonialism and the evils it can bring.
The book is in first person present tense, and it serves the story well.
It’s an Ancient Roman-inspired political fantasy.
It’s partially set in an academy, which gives strong dark academia vibes.
The story has tons of twists and turns!
It has a unique magic system; the society allows a person’s strength, drive, and focus—what they call Will—to be leeched away and added to the power of those in a higher societal position.

It hits on so many hard themes, and despite the chunky page length, I was never bored. While Vis is only 17-years-old, this is definitely an adult book meant for adult audiences. That being said, it appeals to me as a mostly YA reader, as well. If you’re looking for a clever fantasy book, I definitely recommend it!

VERDICT: 🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️/5

Review: House of Flame and Shadow by Sarah J Maas

March 19, 2024March 15, 2024 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

Alexis:

House of Flame and Shadow, the third book in the Crescent City series, has already been controversial in the SJM community, but I really enjoyed it!

It’s not perfect (let’s be honest—ACOTAR (A Court of Thorns and Roses) isn’t either) BUT with the magnitude of everything she had to pull together in House of Flame and Shadow, I thought it was a great, wild ride!

The stakes are high. So many things are happening and being revealed, and despite the massive page count, I was on my toes for all of it. I loved how she pulled everything together!

A lot of people don’t like Bryce, but I’m not one of them. While she’s a little hot-headed, I love a character with actual flaws—and she’s a badass! She also reminded me a lot of Aelin in this book, and a lot of the plot actually reminded me of ACOWAR, the 3rd book in the ACOTAR series.

Two of the side characters were definitely the stars of this book: Lidia and Ruhn. If you know, you know!

House of Earth and Blood is definitely my favorite of the three, and I only gave House of Sky and Breath 3 stars, so it was definitely my least favorite of the bunch. While I think the first book is honestly the best and stands perfectly on its own, I did enjoy this one. I just missed the dynamic of Bryce and Hunt from the first book.

All of that being said, I think Maas did a great job. Sure, the final battle definitely could’ve been a little longer. And sure, there are some info dumps in the first half. But Maas had a lot of things to link together, and overall, this was a great ending. (Or is it the ending? You never know with Maas!)

VERDICT: 5 ⭐

Review: The City of Stardust by Georgia Summers

March 16, 2024April 8, 2024 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

The City of Stardust in front of a desk with a planner and a pink water bottle

Alexis:

Hello! I’m a little behind on book reviews, but I’m excited to talk about one of my recent reads, The City of Stardust.

The City of Stardust follows Violet Everly. Violet’s whole life is her uncles, who keep her tucked away in the Everly house, and wondering what happened to her mother—who left to break the Everly family curse years ago. When Violet’s mother never returns, Penelope, her family’s ageless tormentor who never forgets a debt, issues an ultimatum: Violet has ten years to find her mother, or she will take her place. Violet is the last of the Everly line, the last to suffer. Unless she can break it first.

I really loved this book! It gets all the stars (or stardust) from me.

⁣The writing is so atmospheric, lyrical, and ethereal. This is a dreamy, almost dark fairytale-like story, and on a prose level, it’s gorgeous to read!

It has so many elements that I love—it’s a portal fantasy with magical doors and magical keys. There’s a curse and angry gods. There’s a secretive, snooty group of scholars. There are mysteries that you uncover alongside the main character.

I was so surprised to see that this book only has 3.46 stars on Goodreads.

It is worth mentioning that this is a slower-paced story, and it does take about 50 pages before the worldbuilding becomes revealed and for the plot to pick up. If you like the books/comps listed below or if we have similar tastes in books, then I recommend it!

Ink Blood Sister Scribe

The Ten Thousand Door of January

The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue

Inkheart

The Starless Sea (I personally haven’t read this one, but I heard it’s similar!)

VERDICT: 5⭐

Review: Destroy the Day by Brigid Kemmerer

January 30, 2024January 29, 2024 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

Alexis:

Destroy the Day is the final book in the Defy the Night trilogy, and Defy the Night is one of my favorite books! It’s a classic upper YA fantasy with political intrigue, romance, and a sickness spreading through the land. The two main characters are Tessa, a Robinhood-like apothecary, and Corrick, the prince of Kandala and the King’s Justice.

I really enjoyed Destroy the Day. The story dives deeper into the world, politics, and scheming of the Kandala government. Kemmerer’s writing flows really well, and I feel like her writing style works well when switching between POVs.

Speaking of which, Destroy the Day has three different POVs: Tessa, Corrick, and Corrick’s brother, King Harristan. Harristan’s chapters end up taking up about as much of the book as Tessa and Corrick’s, which honestly, I like! I think Harristan is a great character, and he’s such a good foil to Corrick (stoic and reserved to Corrick’s more hotheadedness).

What I really appreciated about this book was Kemmerer’s talent in making me care about every single character. Usually, I’m not into new, important side characters being introduced later in a series, but Kemmerer does a great job of really showing the impact a new character has on Tessa. A couple of side characters from the second book end up having bigger roles, and I enjoyed watching them grow and help the main characters grow. I especially enjoyed the emphasis on friendship.

Another aspect I really loved about this book is the way no one is a straight-up villain. Kemmerer makes all of her characters well-rounded with solid motivations, so no character is black and white (yep—that means there are some well-written morally gray characters in this series).

Now, I have two main gripes in this book that I’ll delve into more below with spoilers. But the first one is that we get barely any scenes with Tessa and Corrick together. Yes, there are solid reasons for this, but in the end of the book, I really felt like they needed some more scenes together before the resolution. My second gripe is with an important plot point near the end that I feel like didn’t fit into two of the character arcs, which I’ll talk more about below.

All in all, I loved this finale! However, I’m still not over the ending, so I have to dock half a star (or moon, in this case) for that.

VERDICT: 🌑🌑🌑🌑🌓

SPOILERS BELOW:

If you’ve read this book already, or if you don’t care about spoilers, hello! So at the end of this book there is a heartbreaking scene of Harristan sacrificing himself for his country and his brother. While I saw this coming, I came to terms with it because I thought it fit Harristan’s character, as he would do anything to save his brother and his people.

…Until Quint, Harristan’s new boyfriend, decides to help him, and they die together. This felt a little bit too much like the “bury your gays” trope (aka gay characters tend to get killed off).

And then something felt off, and I just had a feeling that neither of them actually died. And while (ding ding!) I was right, the way it was revealed rubbed me the wrong way—Harristan and Quint escaped and survived, only to hear that Corrick had already arrived back home and been crowned king. So what did they do? They hid in a cabin with false identities. And not with the intention of saying, “Oh, hey! We actually survived and we’ll come back to the castle now.” Nope. It was to start a new, secret life.

Harristan’s main motivations were to save Corrick and to save his people. He spent this entire book earning the people of Kandala’s trust back, only to decide to push the burden of being king onto his nineteen-year-old brother, who the people trusted even less than Harristan. You just can’t tell me that it’s in character for him to just say, “Too late! Just spread the lie that we died,” AND let his brother believe it for a long time before managing to slip him a note.

Anyway. Did I still love the book? Yes. It just sucked that this was the twist at the end because I didn’t feel like it fit into Harristan’s character arc—not to mention Quint, who is Corrick’s best friend.

Lesson: Don’t bury your gays! Even if they come back from the dead.

Review: Ruthless Vows by Rebecca Ross

January 16, 2024January 13, 2024 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

Alexis:

Divine Rivals is one of my all-time faves, so it’s an understatement to say I was looking forward to its sequel, Ruthless Vows.

Rebecca Ross’s writing is always lyrical and gorgeous—and it was in Ruthless Vows, as well. I really loved reading this book, but my favorite was definitely the last 3/4. Without going into spoilers, it was heartbreaking, and I loved seeing Iris embrace her badass self.

I docked off a star for 1 main reason:

The pacing in the first half felt off. Certain parts felt too drawn out, and I expected this sequel to be faster paced and more action-packed than the first book, considering the buildup in Divine Rivals and the war.

It’s worth saying that I normally really despise the amnesia trope, but it’s a testimony to Ross’s writing skills that I think she 100% pulled it off.

All in all, I really enjoyed this book, and I’m glad it had a satisfying ending! I’m also grateful that I was able to read this book while I was on my winter vacation.

If you’re looking for a beautifully written upper-YA low fantasy book with WW1 vibes, a war between gods, magical letter writing, and romance, then I highly recommend this duology.

VERDICT: 📚📚📚📚/5

Review: A Study in Drowning by Ava Reid

November 16, 2023January 26, 2024 Anna and Alexis1 Comment

Alexis:

I’m a little behind on reviews, because it sure feels like October flew by. I mean, how is it already almost Thanksgiving? I read a lot of books in October that I haven’t even been able to get to yet! But today, I’m going to talk about A Study in Drowning.

Synopsis:

A Study in Drowning follows Effy, the only female architecture student at her university. When her design to rebuild Hiraeth Manor is chosen, she is partly nervous and partly thrilled. The manor belonged to Emrys Myrddin, the most famous author of her country, before he died. Myrddin’s work is Effy’s all-time favorite. But when she arrives at the manor, she finds a literature student named Preston—who is there to prove that Myrddin was a fraud. As the two students piece together clues about Myrddin’s legacy, dark forces, both mortal and magical, conspire against them—and the truth may bring them both to ruin.

What I Liked:

The star of this book is definitely the atmosphere. I truly felt like I was stuck in the creepy, mysterious, drowning manor. Reid’s descriptions just drip with water and rot; her imagery is both beautiful and visceral.

I also really enjoyed the academic vibes. While this book was marketed as a dark academia, I wouldn’t go so far as to categorize it as such, as only the beginning is set on an actual university campus. I think it has more dark academia vibes with a heavy dose of literature vibes. There are a lot of scenes where Effy and Preston are analyzing the text together and searching for clues, which I thought was really fun and reminded me of my time in grad school.

Myrddin’s epic was about a mortal girl who falls in love with the Fairy King, then destroys him. Effy herself has been having visions of the Fairy King her whole life. I thought this was a very interesting and effective motif throughout the story, as Effy struggles with knowing what is real and what isn’t. This book also deals with sexual assault, abuse, sexism, and mental health, and Reid did a great job of showing how it affected Effy’s life.

What I Didn’t Like As Much:

The plot itself was a little thin at times, and the ending itself felt very rushed compared to the rest of the book.

Most of the characters are pretty unlikeable. I don’t necessarily mind unlikeable characters; having flawed characters makes for a much more interesting story. But Effy herself, who has been a victim of prejudice, does inflict her own prejudices on Preston, which I wasn’t a fan of. The book blurb also says that Effy and Preston are academic rivals, when in reality, Preston does his best to deal with Effy when they first meet because she’s so hostile towards him.

Overall

Overall, I really enjoyed this book. Reid’s prose is gorgeous and atmospheric and transports you directly into the story. I loved the mysteriousness, and I loved the academic and literary vibes. While I do wish the plot and the ending were a little more fleshed out, I was really sucked into this story!

VERDICT: 🌊🌊🌊🌊.5/5

Review: Champion of Fate by Kendare Blake

October 21, 2023October 21, 2023 Anna and AlexisLeave a comment

Alexis:

Champion of Fate follows Reed, an orphan who joins an elite group of immortal warriors called the Aristene. Now, as an initiate, just one challenge stands in her way: she must shepherd her first hero to glory on the battlefield. Succeed, and Reed will take her place beside her sisters.

What I Liked:

I really enjoyed getting to know the Aristene. I loved the worldbuilding and the lore behind them, and I especially enjoyed Reed as a main character. She’s a strong female main character but has plenty of flaws to balance her out. The comradery between this group of female warriors was great, and reminded me of the Amazonian warriors of Greek mythology. In fact, a lot of the world reminded me of Greek mythology, which I’m always down for!

What I Didn’t Like As Much:

The pacing around the middle of this book was a little too slow. It took a long time for Reed to actually start her actual quest of shaping, Hestion, into a hero. There was also a romance that felt very underdeveloped.

However, I think this is a promising start to a series. The world and the Artistene have a lot to offer and explore, and I think there’s a possibility to explore the romance even further.

VERDICT: ⭐⭐⭐⭐/5

Thanks so much to Quill Tree Books for my review copy!